He Shot a Predator that Sexually Assaulted His Daughter & Got Charged

Name: He Shot a Predator that Sexually Assaulted His Daughter & Got Charged
Uploaded: 2026-09-02T13:44:35-07:00
Duration: 1 h 12 min 2 s
Channel: Chris Hansen
Description: Aaron Spencer shares his harrowing experience of saving his daughter from an abducted predator, Michael Fostler, only to be charged with second-degree…

Chris Hansen

01:12:02 Summary & quotes 2 ad segments BETA Report Issue

Loading transcript... Click for full transcript

About this episode Aaron Spencer shares his harrowing experience of saving his daughter from an abducted predator, Michael Fostle… AI summary

Aaron Spencer shares his harrowing experience of saving his daughter from an abducted predator, Michael Fostler, only to be charged with second-degree murder by local authorities. The case highlights severe law enforcement failures, including the loss of critical dash cam evidence and improper handling of the crime scene. Spencer ultimately had the charges dropped due to judicial misconduct and systemic failures, leading him to successfully run for Sheriff of Lonoke County to reform the local justice system.

Key takeaways 5

Aaron Spencer was charged with second-degree murder after shooting Michael Fostler, who had abducted Spencer's daughter from her home while on bail for child exploitation charges.
Law enforcement mishandled critical evidence: body cameras were turned off at the scene, and a dash cam SD card from Fostler's vehicle went missing, preventing exonerating video evidence.
Fostler was released on a $5,000 cash bond with minimal restrictions despite facing 40+ felonies, whereas Spencer was held on a $150,000 bond.
The case was dropped due to due process violations and judicial misconduct, including a judge issuing a vague gag order and displaying willful bias.
Spencer ran for Sheriff of Lonoke County to address systemic failures in the local judicial and law enforcement systems, winning the Republican primary.

Notable quotes 4 AI-generated: wording and quote attribution may be wrong. Use the play link to verify.

“"They were instructed to turn hit the button. And who instructed them to turn off their body cameras? ... I believe it was Detective McCain... that told the rest of the patrol deputies... to turn off their body cameras."”

▶ 49:07 Highlights direct orders from an investigator to destroy potential video evidence of the incident.
“"You can get out of jail for less than the cost of a lawn mower because you're looking at bonds where guys are paying out 1,500, 3,000, 5,000 to get out of jail after... having deviant sexual encounters with children."”

▶ 59:42 Illustrates the perceived corruption and low accountability for sex offenders in the local justice system.
“"I think it has more to do with the judicial system and the sheriff's department and people's pride and egos are trying to protect themselves. I think when you know you think that you are invaluable, um, you know, you can never admit that you're wrong."”

▶ 58:36 Spencer's analysis of why authorities pursued charges against him despite clear self-defense circumstances.
“"It's not like something happens all in one day that's shocking... It's little by little by little and that's the most insidious part about this."”

▶ 8:10 Explains the psychological mechanism of grooming that makes it difficult for victims to report abuse early.