About this episodeThis video analyzes the 1892 murders of Andrew and Abby Bordon in Fall River, Massachusetts, focusing on why t…AI summary
This video analyzes the 1892 murders of Andrew and Abby Bordon in Fall River, Massachusetts, focusing on why their daughter Lizzie Bordon was acquitted despite strong circumstantial evidence. The hosts detail the toxic family dynamics, financial motives, and suspicious behavior such as burning a dress and providing an implausible alibi. The narrative highlights how judicial rulings excluded key evidence like attempted poison purchases and prior testimony, leading to a 'not guilty' verdict that left Lizzie socially ostracized but legally free.
Key takeaways 5
The Bordon household was located in a cramped, poorly designed house on Second Street with no indoor plumbing or electricity, despite Andrew Bordon's significant wealth from cotton mills and real estate investments.
Lizzie Bordon’s alibi for the second murder (her father's death) involved climbing into a hot, sealed barn loft to find lead for fishing sinkers; however, police found the dust in the loft completely undisturbed with no footprints.
Two critical pieces of evidence were excluded from the trial by judges: Lizzie’s contradictory testimony from the preliminary inquest and testimony from a druggist that Lizzie attempted to buy prussic acid (hydrogen cyanide) the day before the murders.
The murders occurred in two distinct waves: Abby Bordon was killed first with approximately 18-19 blows to the head, lying dead for over an hour before Andrew was killed with 10-11 blows to the face while resting on a sofa.
Lizzie burned a blue Bedford cord dress in the kitchen fire days after the murders, claiming it was stained with paint; this destroyed potential forensic evidence regarding blood or other substances.
Notable quotes 3AI-generated: wording and quote attribution may be wrong. Use the play link to verify.
“"Lizzie Bordon took an axe and gave her mother forty strokes. When she saw what she had done, she gave her father forty-one."”
▶ 0:24The famous nursery rhyme that haunted Lizzie Bordon during her lifetime and remains associated with the case today.
“"Suspicion is not proof and beyond a reasonable doubt is the standard. Could you really send a church-going woman to be executed on just a pile of circumstance and inferences?"”
▶ 29:25Argument made by former Governor George Robinson for the defense, highlighting the lack of concrete evidence despite strong motive.
“"She wasn't killed with one clean strike... It was an emotional frenzy. And the truth is, we do not know the exact minute that Abby died."”
▶ 15:29Medical examiner Dr. William Dolan's description of Abby's death, indicating repeated blows rather than a single execution-style strike.
Chapters & Sections (23)▼
0:00Lizzie Borden Case Introduction and Fall River Settingchapter3
2:07Dark Nursery Rhymes and Fall River House
3:31Andrew Borden's Frugal Lifestyle and Home
5:22Lizzie Borden Family Dynamics and Household Staff
8:04Family Resentment and Poisoning Suspicionschapter2
9:49Property Disputes and Inheritance Conflicts
11:29Lizzie Borden Murder Motive Theory
14:00The Borden Murders: Crime Scene and Alibichapter3
16:51Andrew Borden's Discovery and Attack
18:18Lizzie's Barn Loft Alibi
19:57Suspicious Alibi and Burned Dress
22:57Lizzie Borden Trial Evidence and Rulingschapter2
24:36Excluded Evidence of Cyanide Purchase
26:12Prosecution's Weak Evidence and Defense Strategy
28:14Lizzie Borden's Acquittal and Social Ostracismchapter1
30:37Lizzie's Post-Trial Life and Suspects
33:55Unsolved Borden Murders and Testosterone Supplementchapter1
37:08Mars Men Testosterone Supplement Review
39:07Lizzie Borden Murder Motives and Theorieschapter4
41:28Lizzie Borden Poisoning Attempts and Hatchet Murder
1h 40m
1h 59m⏭ 1
45m
1h 33m⏭ 2
2h 1m⏭ 3
48m
55m
2h 20m
1h 2m⏭ 2
3h 17m⏭ 2
47m
43m
11h 23m⏭ 1
1h 0m⏭ 1
33m
46m
3h 54m⏭ 7
48m⏭ 2
3h 59m⏭ 5
40m
1h 13m
38m
54m⏭ 2
54m⏭ 1